An Economic Interpretation of the Constitution of the United States
Beard contends that the authors of The Federalist Papers represented an interest group themselves. ... (1913) and Economic Origins of Jeffersonian Democracy (1915) extended Becker's thesis down to 1800 in terms of class conflict. To Beard, the Constitution was a counter-revolution, set up by rich bond holders (bonds were "personal property"), ...
An Economic Interpretation of the Constitution of the United States
Beard's bombshell book, whose data and interpretations were both praised and challenged, if not denounced, sought to demonstrate that, far from being selfless champions of disinterested ideals, the Founders were largely wealthy and self-interested property owners, whose system of checks and balances was designed to frustrate majority rule to ...
Beard and the Constitution: The History of an Idea
Charles A. Beard's An Economic Interpretation of the Constitution of the United States. The story of its reception and criticism is fa-miliar;' a large part of its thesis has been absorbed into the main body of American historical writing. Beard himself has both de-fended it and expounded some of its limitations. While at first even
PDF The Interpretation of Constitutional History, or Charles Beard Becomes
Beard's demise: A consideration of economic interests can help illuminate the ideology of the founding. To be sure, Beard missed most of the story of the founding, but his economic approach can still add an important element to the discussion. Plus, as I explain, despite Beard's historical errors, he has become a prescient for-tuneteller.
Rehabilitation of Charles A. Beard
thesis, an analysis of the relationship between economic interests and voting patterns in the formation and ratification of the Constitution is. important in its own right. In analyzing the relationship between. economic interests and voting behavior, we do not mean to suggest. " Main, "Charles A. Beard," pp. 92-102.
Economic Interests and the American Constitution: A Quantitative
5 Although we believe this paragraph accurately reflects Charles Beard's thesis, other scholars may not agree. Beard's An Economic Interpretation is confusing because he uses terms imprecisely, continuously interchanging "economic interest" with "class interest," "class" with "group," and "economic interpretation" with "economic determinism."
Charles Beard and the Constitution: A Critical Analysis on JSTOR
From the moment of its debut, An Economic Interpretation of the Constitution of the United States by Charles A. Beard was a subject of heated controversy. Few books in American history have aroused such bitter partisanship; few have elicited the extremes of both commendation and condemnation that were heaped on this single volume.¹.
Power and Authority in American History: The Case of Charles A. Beard
Beard's thesis came as a revelation to scholars and intellectuals who hailed it for undermining the patriotic banalities of nineteenth-century historiography. Conventional wisdom decreed that the Constitution was the work of Provi-dence's guiding hand, the fruit of the genius of Teutonic legal traditions, or the ...
Charles Beard and the Constitution : a critical analysis of "An
In this work, Robert E. Brown applies the fruits of modern historical scholarship toward an understanding of Beard's groundbreaking and controversial work. With a perspective of forty years, Brown attempts to separate the valid from the bogus in this work Includes bibliographical references
Liberty, Education, and the Economic Interpretation of the Constitution
This conference, marked the centenary of Charles Beard's An Economic Interpretation of the Constitution of the United States, examined the "Beard thesis" by reading key selections of Beard's original book, important critiques of Beard by Forrest McDonald, Martin Diamond, and others, and then considered the resurgence of "neo-Beardianism" among contemporary historians and political ...
Charles Beard & the U.S. Constitution
Beard's interpretation is considered progressive history, which is the ideologically and/or politically progressive interpretation of history and a school of thought which emphasizes economic ...
PDF Personalty interests at the Constitutional Convention: new tests of the
Surprisingly, few of these motions were alluded to by Beard as critical to the interests of those who owned personalty (described in detail below). 2.1 Beard's thesis Prior to Beard's work, most studies of the Constitutional Convention argued that the framers who attended the Convention were disinterested statesmen who tried to
A Revaluation of the Beard Thesis of the Making of the Constitution
Beard asserted that public securities were the dynamic element within the dynamic element in the ratification. There were, indeed, some holders of public securities among the opponents of the Constitution and, contrary to Beard's assertion, they were as numerous as the security holders among the supporters of the Constitution.
Charles A. Beard
Charles A. Beard (born November 27, 1874, near Knightstown, Indiana, U.S.—died September 1, 1948, New Haven, Connecticut) was an American historian, best known for his iconoclastic studies of the development of U.S. political institutions. His emphasis on the dynamics of socioeconomic conflict and change and his analysis of motivational ...
PDF Charles A. Beard
Excerpted from Charles Beard's "Framing the Constitution," in Peter Woll, ed., American Government: Readings and Cases, 11th ed. (New York: Harper Collins, 1993) In the following essay, which is adapted from The Supreme Court and the Constitution (1912), Charles Beard presents evidence that the framers of the Constitution were less interested ...
Charles A. Beard
Charles Austin Beard (November 27, 1874 - September 1, 1948) was an American historian and professor, who wrote primarily during the first half of the 20th century. A history professor at Columbia University, Beard's influence is primarily due to his publications in the fields of history and political science.His works included a radical re-evaluation of the Founding Fathers of the United ...
Charles Austin Beard's Economic Interpretation of the American Century
98 Against Beard, Thomas C. Kennedy strongly supports the foreign policy decisions of FDR in the run-up to American involvement in the Second World War while acknowledging that 'particulars of his indictment have been conceded', in Charles A. Beard and American Foreign Policy (Gainesville, 1975), 165. Kennedy grants Beard's charge of the ...
Personalty interests at the Constitutional Convention: new tests of the
2.1 Beard's thesis. Prior to Beard's work, most studies of the Constitutional Convention argued that the framers who attended the Convention were disinterested statesmen who tried to enact various principles of democracy. Beard challenged this view by arguing that particular types of property largely affected how delegates voted. Footnote 2
We the People
No historian who followed in studying the making of the Constitution was entirely free from Beard's radical interpretation of the document as serving the economic interests of the Framers as members of the propertied class. Forrest McDonald's We the People was the first major challenge to Beard's thesis. This superbly researched and documented ...
Charles A. Beard and the Constitution: A Critical Review of Forrest
Beard stresses James Wilson's large estate, McDonald his debts and ultimate poverty. To McDonald, Hamilton was "perpetually in debt"; to Beard, he is the principal spokesman for the rich, who "lived well, and had a large income." Madison is depicted by McDonald as the owner of "560 ill-kept acres," by Beard as the son of a wealthy planter,
The Beard Thesis and Franklin Roosevelt
Cass R. Sunstein, The Beard Thesis and Franklin Roosevelt, 56 Geo. Wash. L. Rev. 114 (1987).
The Beard Thesis and the Seinfeld Defense
The Beard Thesis and the Seinfeld Defense. In this, its centennial year, Charles Beard's 1913 An Economic Interpretation of the Constitution of the United States retains its hold on both the publication market and, at least in certain circles, the popular imagination. Its claim that the Founders were possessive aristocrats out to protect the ...
'An Economic Interpretation of The Constitution' After Fifty Years
The ambiguities in Beard's thesis have been recognized for many years by adherents and critics alike. The most important of these, because it is absolutely central to his argument, is the question of precisely what Beard meant by the terms economic interpretation and economic determinism. Beard chose the former of these as the title for his ...
IMAGES
VIDEO
COMMENTS
Beard contends that the authors of The Federalist Papers represented an interest group themselves. ... (1913) and Economic Origins of Jeffersonian Democracy (1915) extended Becker's thesis down to 1800 in terms of class conflict. To Beard, the Constitution was a counter-revolution, set up by rich bond holders (bonds were "personal property"), ...
Beard's bombshell book, whose data and interpretations were both praised and challenged, if not denounced, sought to demonstrate that, far from being selfless champions of disinterested ideals, the Founders were largely wealthy and self-interested property owners, whose system of checks and balances was designed to frustrate majority rule to ...
Charles A. Beard's An Economic Interpretation of the Constitution of the United States. The story of its reception and criticism is fa-miliar;' a large part of its thesis has been absorbed into the main body of American historical writing. Beard himself has both de-fended it and expounded some of its limitations. While at first even
Beard's demise: A consideration of economic interests can help illuminate the ideology of the founding. To be sure, Beard missed most of the story of the founding, but his economic approach can still add an important element to the discussion. Plus, as I explain, despite Beard's historical errors, he has become a prescient for-tuneteller.
thesis, an analysis of the relationship between economic interests and voting patterns in the formation and ratification of the Constitution is. important in its own right. In analyzing the relationship between. economic interests and voting behavior, we do not mean to suggest. " Main, "Charles A. Beard," pp. 92-102.
5 Although we believe this paragraph accurately reflects Charles Beard's thesis, other scholars may not agree. Beard's An Economic Interpretation is confusing because he uses terms imprecisely, continuously interchanging "economic interest" with "class interest," "class" with "group," and "economic interpretation" with "economic determinism."
From the moment of its debut, An Economic Interpretation of the Constitution of the United States by Charles A. Beard was a subject of heated controversy. Few books in American history have aroused such bitter partisanship; few have elicited the extremes of both commendation and condemnation that were heaped on this single volume.¹.
Beard's thesis came as a revelation to scholars and intellectuals who hailed it for undermining the patriotic banalities of nineteenth-century historiography. Conventional wisdom decreed that the Constitution was the work of Provi-dence's guiding hand, the fruit of the genius of Teutonic legal traditions, or the ...
In this work, Robert E. Brown applies the fruits of modern historical scholarship toward an understanding of Beard's groundbreaking and controversial work. With a perspective of forty years, Brown attempts to separate the valid from the bogus in this work Includes bibliographical references
This conference, marked the centenary of Charles Beard's An Economic Interpretation of the Constitution of the United States, examined the "Beard thesis" by reading key selections of Beard's original book, important critiques of Beard by Forrest McDonald, Martin Diamond, and others, and then considered the resurgence of "neo-Beardianism" among contemporary historians and political ...
Beard's interpretation is considered progressive history, which is the ideologically and/or politically progressive interpretation of history and a school of thought which emphasizes economic ...
Surprisingly, few of these motions were alluded to by Beard as critical to the interests of those who owned personalty (described in detail below). 2.1 Beard's thesis Prior to Beard's work, most studies of the Constitutional Convention argued that the framers who attended the Convention were disinterested statesmen who tried to
Beard asserted that public securities were the dynamic element within the dynamic element in the ratification. There were, indeed, some holders of public securities among the opponents of the Constitution and, contrary to Beard's assertion, they were as numerous as the security holders among the supporters of the Constitution.
Charles A. Beard (born November 27, 1874, near Knightstown, Indiana, U.S.—died September 1, 1948, New Haven, Connecticut) was an American historian, best known for his iconoclastic studies of the development of U.S. political institutions. His emphasis on the dynamics of socioeconomic conflict and change and his analysis of motivational ...
Excerpted from Charles Beard's "Framing the Constitution," in Peter Woll, ed., American Government: Readings and Cases, 11th ed. (New York: Harper Collins, 1993) In the following essay, which is adapted from The Supreme Court and the Constitution (1912), Charles Beard presents evidence that the framers of the Constitution were less interested ...
Charles Austin Beard (November 27, 1874 - September 1, 1948) was an American historian and professor, who wrote primarily during the first half of the 20th century. A history professor at Columbia University, Beard's influence is primarily due to his publications in the fields of history and political science.His works included a radical re-evaluation of the Founding Fathers of the United ...
98 Against Beard, Thomas C. Kennedy strongly supports the foreign policy decisions of FDR in the run-up to American involvement in the Second World War while acknowledging that 'particulars of his indictment have been conceded', in Charles A. Beard and American Foreign Policy (Gainesville, 1975), 165. Kennedy grants Beard's charge of the ...
2.1 Beard's thesis. Prior to Beard's work, most studies of the Constitutional Convention argued that the framers who attended the Convention were disinterested statesmen who tried to enact various principles of democracy. Beard challenged this view by arguing that particular types of property largely affected how delegates voted. Footnote 2
No historian who followed in studying the making of the Constitution was entirely free from Beard's radical interpretation of the document as serving the economic interests of the Framers as members of the propertied class. Forrest McDonald's We the People was the first major challenge to Beard's thesis. This superbly researched and documented ...
Beard stresses James Wilson's large estate, McDonald his debts and ultimate poverty. To McDonald, Hamilton was "perpetually in debt"; to Beard, he is the principal spokesman for the rich, who "lived well, and had a large income." Madison is depicted by McDonald as the owner of "560 ill-kept acres," by Beard as the son of a wealthy planter,
Cass R. Sunstein, The Beard Thesis and Franklin Roosevelt, 56 Geo. Wash. L. Rev. 114 (1987).
The Beard Thesis and the Seinfeld Defense. In this, its centennial year, Charles Beard's 1913 An Economic Interpretation of the Constitution of the United States retains its hold on both the publication market and, at least in certain circles, the popular imagination. Its claim that the Founders were possessive aristocrats out to protect the ...
The ambiguities in Beard's thesis have been recognized for many years by adherents and critics alike. The most important of these, because it is absolutely central to his argument, is the question of precisely what Beard meant by the terms economic interpretation and economic determinism. Beard chose the former of these as the title for his ...